Driving Forward > Digital Marketing Blog

The Creepiest Ad I’ve Seen Yet


Our lives and the things around us are becoming more personalized. In medicine, personalized therapy based on specific genetic mutations can help boost drug efficacy and improve patient outcomes. In education, personalized learning tailored to the wants and needs of individuals is considered by some to be the next big thing in education. And in advertising, personalized ad content driven by your perceived interests is becoming more prevalent daily.

But can personalized advertising become too creepy? Some consumers already consider remarketing creepy. As an advertiser who employs it daily, I believe its usefulness far out-weighs the “creepy” factor. But a number of other methods of highly-targeted advertising are upon us, and they’ll only keep coming. However, this one, served to me last night via Facebook’s mobile app, really caught me by surprise:

(Hint: my last name is Shapiro)

Shapiro Ad in Facebook

My gut reaction: creepy. Why? Maybe because I (as a paid search specialist but not a social media guru) am not familiar with the exact inner-workings of Facebook’s Ads Manager. But really, I think it’s more because of the use of personally identifiable information (PII). Digging in a bit further, it appears as though this instance is not a breach of PII laws, as the ad only uses my (fairly common) last name. But nonetheless, how much personalization is too much? Being served ads for websites I’ve recently visited is one thing, but having my last name explicitly used in an ad when I have had no previous interaction with the advertiser is a different story.

At our weekly agency meeting, we at Overdrive discussed what we believe will be the hottest trends in 2014. The winner: highly-targeted personalized advertising. No doubt, personalization will play a huge role in advertising moving forward, but I think something to keep a close eye on is when does the “creepy” factor raise that red flag and present more of a turn-off than a valuable marketing strategy?




How AI is Reshaping Digital Marketing


Artificial Intelligence design studios are opening everywhere, adding to our marketing technology stack choices. Many platforms have already integrated components of AI into their existing marketing system offerings. Clients need to transform digitally, squared Today, clients are asking digital marketing and advertising agencies like Overdrive to embrace more technological change, as their marketing tech stacks grow…

Read the full article

Contact Us

Schedule a presentation. Tell us about your marketing goals. Find our offices. Or, just say hello. We would love to hear from you!

Contact Us   


Artificial Intelligence Marketing Map

Learn to navigate the ever-changing landscape of Artificial Intelligence Marketing.

Get Access!   


Social Media Map

Explore the evolving social media marketing landscape. Live links to more than 390 sites, apps, and tools broken down into 25 categories.

Get Access!   


Search Marketing Map

Learn to navigate the ever changing landscape of Search Marketing. Live links to over 281 websites, apps, tools, and events, broken into 26 categories.

Get Access!   
Dev Tool:

Request: the-creepiest-ad-ive-seen-yet
Matched Rewrite Rule: ([^/]+)(?:/([0-9]+))?/?$
Matched Rewrite Query: name=the-creepiest-ad-ive-seen-yet&page=
Loaded Template: single.php